pennswoods (![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
pennswoods) wrote2013-08-12 04:34 pm
pennswoods) wrote2013-08-12 04:34 pm
Entry tags:
Thoughts from a Cumberbitch
Below is the meta piece I wrote for Episode 8 of ![[livejournal.com profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/external/lj-community.gif)
threepatch. I've copied it here in full below and for those who are on Tumblr, here's the original post.
* * *
This is the last of three essays on the Cumberbitch Question featured in Episode 8 (What’s it Like in your Funny Little Brains?) of the Three Patch Podcast. In this response to Drinkingocoa’s essay, Shannon explains why she finds the term Cumberbitch empowering and is troubled by attempts to erase this fan identity.
(Warning for mention of child sexual abuse)
My name is Shannon. I appreciate the different fan identities in the Sherlock fandom and the reasons why many other fans do not identify as Cumberbitches. At the same time I worry that statements from Benedict and from other fans are making it too easy to condemn this fan term without understanding that some of us are using it as a sign of humor, celebration and even empowerment. ‘Bitch' is a word that has been used to demean and silence women, but it is also a rally cry reclaimed by some against sexist assumptions. To only recognize the negative connotations of bitch grants too much power to those who wish to use it to silence and mock women while erasing the very painful and joyous experiences of other fans who have reclaimed it.
I am an enthusiastically unapologetic Cumberbitch and this is why.
One weekend in June, when I was 11 years old, my father followed me into the bathroom and sexually molested me. This was the first of what became progressively more physical encounters he perpetrated against me over the next year and a half. Yet the greatest trauma I must deal with as a result of this sexual abuse does not stem from the physical violation. It stems from the utter violation of my autonomy and the resulting constant fear that at some point in my life, someone else will again impose their will upon me and remove my choice, my agency so completely. It keeps me on guard and is why I push back against attempts to disempower me and others, whether these attempts are well-intended or not, whether they take the form of government legislation, peer pressure, or the use of propriety to shame and silence. Sometimes my pushing back takes the form of logical debate and angry words. But other times, especially in fandom, my pushing back takes the form of cheeky humor and unrestrained celebration.
Growing up in the southern United States, I encountered many terms used to control and silence women and girls: babe, whore, bitch, slut, girl, lesbian, lady, miss, missy, woman. Some were dangerously successful because they were the least taboo and could be said in any context and appear to be meant kindly: Remember girls, always act like a lady because a lady who respects herself will be respected by men. The tenets of rape culture appeared proper and harder to argue against when wrapped up in respectful language. How nicely said. How effectively controlling. How insidious. At the same time, other words were reserved for moments of maximum damage and debasement. “Shut up bitch!”, "Stupid bitch!”, "Don’t be such a bitch!” were overt attempts to disempower and cause offense through the use of taboo language. But words are not inherently good or bad; they derive their power from context and use. As an applied linguist, I see this often in my own research on the teaching and learning of English. And as a high school girl growing up in the Deep South, I encountered the fluidity of language in sports, an area that challenged gender expectations.
‘Bitch' was the favored insult directed towards me and my fellow teammates on the high school girls soccer team by members of the boys team who used it to maintain their sense of superiority over us during and after practice. We were transgressing on their turf, after all. 'Bitch' was a word of warning uttered by my teammates' parents who wanted to remind us not to let our physical aggressiveness on the field transfer off the field when dating or interacting with boys and parents and teachers. But my own experience at the hand of my father had shown me that being proper and good didn’t guarantee respect. ‘Bitch' was the word of condemnation uttered by our coach toward the more experienced and strategy-minded girls on the team who questioned his play-making. Hearing 'bitch' used in these contexts made me feel small and fearful and self-doubting. It triggered a feeling of powerlessness and hopelessness in me because it signaled that my attempts to maintain control over my body and to assert my agency and preferences were offensive, dangerous, or wrong.
But gradually, among my fellow teammates, ‘bitch’ became the word we used with playfulness and camaraderie and support when we chose to fight against attempts to control and belittle us. We ripped the teeth out of it and made it our own. Instead of conveying insult and contempt, ‘You bitch’ showed admiration and respect for someone who was capable and clever and assertive. It conveyed support for someone willing to take a risk. It was a rejection of sexism masquerading as propriety. It was how we laughed at others who thought using this word to ridicule our physicality, our assertiveness and our enthusiasm for unladylike behavior was an effective way to control us. To hear ‘bitch' used this way filled me with a sense of possibility and pleasure in my own potential strength and sexuality and autonomy. It became a word that made me aware of my strength and which I drew upon in the face of those who tried to deride or disempower me.
When I became a fan of Benedict Cumberbatch and encountered the term Cumberbitch, I laughed at the play on his name and recognized the same reappropriation at work. I felt that same growling sense of pleasure. Here were fans like me declaring their enthusiasm for a clever logophile like Benedict as well as a playful defiance toward those who mock us and are discomfited by the geeky ardor and sexual fervor of fans and fangirls in particular. Here was a space for me to continue the work of overcoming the lingering effects of sexual abuse by embracing my own desires and will alongside other fans who were not afraid to express their desires and sexual agency publicly. Cumberbitch encapsulates my joy and one of my reasons for being a fan - to push back through celebration and creativity against those who wish to control me. I call myself a Cumberbitch knowingly and with humor because I have made bitch my own. To shut down or deride the use of Cumberbitch as a fandom identity because it contains a taboo word is to erase the experiences and mark of empowerment for fans like me.
Other meta in this series:
threepatch. I've copied it here in full below and for those who are on Tumblr, here's the original post.* * *
This is the last of three essays on the Cumberbitch Question featured in Episode 8 (What’s it Like in your Funny Little Brains?) of the Three Patch Podcast. In this response to Drinkingocoa’s essay, Shannon explains why she finds the term Cumberbitch empowering and is troubled by attempts to erase this fan identity.
(Warning for mention of child sexual abuse)
My name is Shannon. I appreciate the different fan identities in the Sherlock fandom and the reasons why many other fans do not identify as Cumberbitches. At the same time I worry that statements from Benedict and from other fans are making it too easy to condemn this fan term without understanding that some of us are using it as a sign of humor, celebration and even empowerment. ‘Bitch' is a word that has been used to demean and silence women, but it is also a rally cry reclaimed by some against sexist assumptions. To only recognize the negative connotations of bitch grants too much power to those who wish to use it to silence and mock women while erasing the very painful and joyous experiences of other fans who have reclaimed it.
I am an enthusiastically unapologetic Cumberbitch and this is why.
One weekend in June, when I was 11 years old, my father followed me into the bathroom and sexually molested me. This was the first of what became progressively more physical encounters he perpetrated against me over the next year and a half. Yet the greatest trauma I must deal with as a result of this sexual abuse does not stem from the physical violation. It stems from the utter violation of my autonomy and the resulting constant fear that at some point in my life, someone else will again impose their will upon me and remove my choice, my agency so completely. It keeps me on guard and is why I push back against attempts to disempower me and others, whether these attempts are well-intended or not, whether they take the form of government legislation, peer pressure, or the use of propriety to shame and silence. Sometimes my pushing back takes the form of logical debate and angry words. But other times, especially in fandom, my pushing back takes the form of cheeky humor and unrestrained celebration.
Growing up in the southern United States, I encountered many terms used to control and silence women and girls: babe, whore, bitch, slut, girl, lesbian, lady, miss, missy, woman. Some were dangerously successful because they were the least taboo and could be said in any context and appear to be meant kindly: Remember girls, always act like a lady because a lady who respects herself will be respected by men. The tenets of rape culture appeared proper and harder to argue against when wrapped up in respectful language. How nicely said. How effectively controlling. How insidious. At the same time, other words were reserved for moments of maximum damage and debasement. “Shut up bitch!”, "Stupid bitch!”, "Don’t be such a bitch!” were overt attempts to disempower and cause offense through the use of taboo language. But words are not inherently good or bad; they derive their power from context and use. As an applied linguist, I see this often in my own research on the teaching and learning of English. And as a high school girl growing up in the Deep South, I encountered the fluidity of language in sports, an area that challenged gender expectations.
‘Bitch' was the favored insult directed towards me and my fellow teammates on the high school girls soccer team by members of the boys team who used it to maintain their sense of superiority over us during and after practice. We were transgressing on their turf, after all. 'Bitch' was a word of warning uttered by my teammates' parents who wanted to remind us not to let our physical aggressiveness on the field transfer off the field when dating or interacting with boys and parents and teachers. But my own experience at the hand of my father had shown me that being proper and good didn’t guarantee respect. ‘Bitch' was the word of condemnation uttered by our coach toward the more experienced and strategy-minded girls on the team who questioned his play-making. Hearing 'bitch' used in these contexts made me feel small and fearful and self-doubting. It triggered a feeling of powerlessness and hopelessness in me because it signaled that my attempts to maintain control over my body and to assert my agency and preferences were offensive, dangerous, or wrong.
But gradually, among my fellow teammates, ‘bitch’ became the word we used with playfulness and camaraderie and support when we chose to fight against attempts to control and belittle us. We ripped the teeth out of it and made it our own. Instead of conveying insult and contempt, ‘You bitch’ showed admiration and respect for someone who was capable and clever and assertive. It conveyed support for someone willing to take a risk. It was a rejection of sexism masquerading as propriety. It was how we laughed at others who thought using this word to ridicule our physicality, our assertiveness and our enthusiasm for unladylike behavior was an effective way to control us. To hear ‘bitch' used this way filled me with a sense of possibility and pleasure in my own potential strength and sexuality and autonomy. It became a word that made me aware of my strength and which I drew upon in the face of those who tried to deride or disempower me.
When I became a fan of Benedict Cumberbatch and encountered the term Cumberbitch, I laughed at the play on his name and recognized the same reappropriation at work. I felt that same growling sense of pleasure. Here were fans like me declaring their enthusiasm for a clever logophile like Benedict as well as a playful defiance toward those who mock us and are discomfited by the geeky ardor and sexual fervor of fans and fangirls in particular. Here was a space for me to continue the work of overcoming the lingering effects of sexual abuse by embracing my own desires and will alongside other fans who were not afraid to express their desires and sexual agency publicly. Cumberbitch encapsulates my joy and one of my reasons for being a fan - to push back through celebration and creativity against those who wish to control me. I call myself a Cumberbitch knowingly and with humor because I have made bitch my own. To shut down or deride the use of Cumberbitch as a fandom identity because it contains a taboo word is to erase the experiences and mark of empowerment for fans like me.
Other meta in this series:
- The Cumberbitch Question - Meta by Drinkingcocoa
- Methleigh’s Response
- Katie’s Response
no subject
no subject
One of the things I really appreciate about the Three Patch Podcast is that its members don't always agree but we are able to respect the perspectives of others and we wanted to capture this a bit (fandom is far more diverse than we are) in this series.
no subject
no subject
Drinkingcocoa beta'd this for me to wrangle it into its current state. It took weeks!
no subject
Bitch is the new "black", huh?
no subject
*hugs back*
I'll be giving you one of those in person soon!
no subject
We ripped the teeth out of it and made it our own.
That's such a powerful statement. I guess for some people it's just really difficult to look past the history of certain words in order to see how positively they're being reclaimed. For example, I think perhaps Benedict is under the impression that someone (presumably male) chose the term "Cumberbitches" for his fans instead of his fans choosing the term for themselves and re-appropriating the word.
no subject
And thank you for sharing your response to my words. This essay took me weeks to write and revise and wrestle into shape. Sometimes it's hard to write about something I feel so viscerally.
I have no doubt that Benedict is coming from a very different position from me and in that position he is doing what is fair and respectful to the fans he is aware of. I don't know that he is imagining people like me. And this is part of the reason why I spoke up. Neither the media (which has latched on to the term Cumberbitch to mock and poke fun) or Benedict (who seems a bit worried for us) reflect what I am and certainly some other fans mean when we call ourselves this.
Thank you for reading and commenting.
no subject
...to push back through celebration and creativity against those who wish to control me.
God yes. This IS fandom to me. We are born pushers. Questioners. Fillers in of empty space. Wordsmiths. Line blurrers. Gleeful scribblers. Beholden to none. No canon is sacred.
As a fan of Heartless Bitches International back when it updated frequently and a former subscriber to Bitch magazine when I had time to read them, "bitch" is one of my favorite reclaimed words. For me, Cumberbitch is a great joke that we collectively made.
I agree, BC himself is probably uncomfortable with the term because he doesn't want to be seen as the sort of person who uses the word bitch in a derogatory manner. And he'd never want to apply it to the people who are his fans.
I strongly suspect he'd love this argument in favor of it, but the wide world, especially the popular press, is no place for such nuanced distinctions.
no subject
I am sure Benedict's experiences with the term are very different from mine and if he knew of people like me, he might phrase things a little differently. But even if he doesn't, that's okay. I don't need his permission to be a fan and to adapt an identity that reflects my experiences and reality. I did want to put it out there and have it on record.
no subject
I was abused verbally by my father who always said I was nothing and I will never achieve nothing until today I'm 40 he says i'm a failure and make me cry even if I know he is the one who failed and I'm happy with my life, but he has the power to disarm me, it is terrible! I didn't talk with him for years, but he is very sick (I don't live with him!!) and I saw him little every year but he still treat me so offensively.
I was molested and raped after in life, not by him. But I understand you society thinks it is ok for my father to mistreat me, and for this other men to try or succeed in rape me, because i'm a woman.
I think words are brutal can hurt and liberate.
I loved cumberbitches because as men can be "Bad mother fuckers" and that is empowering why "BAD bitch" don't
also we Cumberbach fans are different from other fans, it is said that Ben is not really beautiful, himself doesn't believe it.
we see more then the simple blond poster guy! we can see quality we see beauty, because we observe we listen.
we are awesome!!
we are great bad bitches!
but I think Ben who study in a posh British school even if he isn't posh himself he doesn't get the term like in whole sense of it and also apparently he is very shy and had not to much confidence in himself he thinks good actor, not beautiful or sexy.
maybe he needs us to understand openness and new visions of words, of views on beautiful, of empowering and true strength!
i think Martin get that part better, but we are here for Ben to teach him
than we are proud!
no subject
I too like the badness feeling of bitch. When men call women bitches, it can signal that they're afraid and threatened. It's nice not to be the one fearing for a change.
And I agree that Benedict's background and experiences with the word is going to be different. And as a man, he may need to be more careful about what words he uses to refer to women. I don't mind that he not use it, but I also am not afraid to disagree with his comment about it setting feminism back.
no subject
Yay, you!!!
no subject
no subject
I personally have always kind of adored the term 'Cumberbitch' - fandom reaction has made me feel a bit guilty over it, but the play on words is irresistible to me. Not just the name, the 'female' aspect of it, but the 'to be someone's bitch' connotations as well. It just works too well to pass up.
Reading your meta makes me feel less guilty about it, which I see as a good thing *g*
I don't think you were on my f-list when I took this straw poll, but the people who came out of the woodwork (weren't even on my f-list) just to call it 'heinous' quite surprised me and I haven't been quite game to use it in public since. Maybe I should...
http://daasgrrl.livejournal.com/130903.html
The fandom police do bother me, but I suppose I should just get over it.
no subject
I wasn't around for this straw poll and I almost have half a mind to do one of my own, but I think coming out with the above post would mean people wouldn't feel comfortable disagreeing with me.
The fandom police bother me too. Their methods remind me way too much of the ethical/religious policing of my youth.
no subject
A poll from you would be interesting, even if it did show a certain amount of bias.
no subject
no subject